Mountaineers and conservationists have condemned the Scottish Government’s decision to give the go-ahead to a major windfarm in the Monadhliath Mountains.
The Mountaineering Council of Scotland said the Holyrood administration seemed oblivious to the effects of such developments on tourism.
Energy minister Fergus Ewing approved the SSE scheme to build 67 turbines at Stronelairg, each of which would be as high as the Forth Road Bridge’s towers.
The John Muir Trust, the conservation charity that owns most of Ben Nevis, said it would destroy the character of the area.
The development will be in the heart of a proposed core area of wild land mapped by Scottish Natural Heritage, the Government’s advisory body on the outdoors. It is the largest windfarm so far approved in the Highland region.
Helen McDade, head of policy for the John Muir Trust said: “This development flies in the face of advice from Scottish Natural Heritage which objected to the development on the grounds that it would destroy the character of one of Scotland’s key areas of wild land.
“SSE is a powerful multinational company with its HQ in Scotland, and we know this project is worth many hundreds of millions to its shareholders.
“It is unfortunate that SSE’s views seem to hold greater sway over ministers than the opinions of the Scottish Government’s own expert body on the natural environment.
“We are concerned about the wider implications of this decision for the future of wild land across Scotland.
“The Stronelairg Wind Farm is a massive industrial development in the heart of the Monadhliath Mountains – area 17 of the core areas of wild land map.
“This decision would suggest that the Scottish Government intends either to remove the Monadhliaths from the wild land map, or to render the entire map meaningless.
“We will continue to fight for wild land in Scotland.”
Colin Nicol, SEE’s lead director of wholesale generation development, said: “SSE is delighted with the decision from Scottish ministers on Stronelairg windfarm.
“It is a fantastic project which will bring real socio-economic benefits to the Great Glen area including job creation, skills training, business opportunities and substantial community funds.
“When planning Stronelairg, we worked very closely with these communities and stakeholders to minimise any local impacts and this includes utilising the existing Glendoe hydro access road infrastructure
“We are keen to ensure that local businesses are afforded as many opportunities as possible during construction. We estimate as much as £120m could be secured by Highland and other Scottish companies, and that significant local employment opportunities will be created.
“In addition, SSE will be providing up to £30m of community funds for 25 years from the construction start.”
Willie Cameron, boss of Drumnadrochit-based bakers Cobbs, which produced 12,000 cupcakes for employees of energy company N-power to mark the 2012 Olympics, said: “This is brilliant news for the Great Glen and for local people.
“I believe it has been well sited and carefully designed and it will have zero effect on tourism as a result.”
But David Gibson, chief officer of the Mountaineering Council of Scotland, said: “The MCofS objected to Stronelairg because it will be a massively intrusive industrial development located on a 700m-high plateau, meaning that the height of turbines will extend to more than 800m above sea level (2,500ft) and be visible from mountains for miles around and from the Cairngorms national park.
“The Scottish Government appears to be oblivious to the adverse impacts of such developments on tourism. Even research studies sponsored by the renewables industry itself already show a worrying and serious trend in the adverse impact on visitor intentions, based on their perceptions of windfarm developments.
“The Scottish Government will publish its latest planning policy on 23 June in which it will lay out the measures by which it aims to protect Scotland’s world-renowned landscape from onshore windfarm developments.
“If Stronelairg is indicative of the value it places on our landscape, there seems to be little hope for its future, and for that of the many businesses and thousands of jobs in rural communities which rely on tourists who come to Scotland for its landscape, unless strong protective measures are put in place.”
Highland Council gave approval for the development in April last year, but final say on the scheme lay with the Scottish Government.
Iain Welsh
06 June 2014I'll have ta vote NO then :o)
D Bannister
06 June 2014Well I will be adding to global warming then as I'd rather fly abroad to somewhere that's not ruined.
David
07 June 2014"...visible from mountains for miles around and from the Cairngorms national park".
So depressing.
Eric Scott
07 June 2014Once again our glorius Scottish Government has ridden rough shod over public opinion. It is the same with fish farms as well. One can see where independance will take us a dictatorship.
mick
07 June 2014I backpacked in the area last week and was awe struck looking into the heart of the Monadhiath. Sadly I went specifically to get a view of it before it was despoiled. Disgraceful. I wont be back anytime soon and would rather take my tourist money elsewhere.
GeorgeH
07 June 2014Some facts for Fergus Ewing. The Tasmanian wedge-tailed eagle is threatened with global extinction by wind farms. Recent research from around the world indicates horrific bird mortality rates:- SPAIN - 330 birds per turbine per year, GERMANY - 309 birds per turbine per year, SWEDEN - 895 birds per turbine per year. When will Mr Ewing tell us the Scottish figures?
NeilD
07 June 2014It's 2014 and we build windmills,for goodness sake!
TH
07 June 2014Newtonmore no more for me. Glad I spent a week's holiday there last year.
I'll spend my English pounds on an English holiday in future Mr Salmond.
David
07 June 2014I will be now voting NO for a government that I cannot trust to hold the very thing which every Scotsman holds dear. But a few.
Lakesbloke
08 June 2014Aye as ever they have their eyes on the wrong prize! The Scottish government want to mix it with the big boys but fall short!
Jane
08 June 2014I too trekked across the Monadhliath last year and have been back this year, all because I reckoned the inevitable was about to happen. I'd just finished showing my mum some photos and saying, "That's where they want to put a huge wind farm ... ", when I opened the newspaper and saw the (tiny) headline buried amidst other news.
Shame on the SNP for their environmental barbarism. Shame on the Scots for their apathy. If more people protested and protested more vociferously even the bloated bombast would have to take notice.
John
09 June 2014John Muir will visit Salmond/Ewing one dark night and show them the error of their ways.
I'd love that to happen . . .
Charles Britten
10 June 2014Unfortunately, Alec Salmond won't be bothered about spoiling the mountains. After all, he doesn't exactly look like he's spent much time exercising in the outdoors, does he?
jimmyr
10 June 2014Jane - may be up against it with views like this that I saw on another site, "If a condition of independence was bulldozing all the mountains to the ground I would still vote yes."
Jeff breen
10 June 2014Scientific studies suggest wind farms built on peatlands release large amounts of co2. It then takes about 25 yrs for the turbine to compensate for that loss. Peat loss is caused by foundations infrastructure and access roads destroying it.
So all that landscape damage for zero benefit.
jimmyr
11 June 2014I should have added that the comment above (about bulldozing) was made by a Munro Bagger.
OutdoorsAndy
14 June 2014FOLLOW THE MONEY! This stinks of cronyism, there will be friends that have vested interests in this. It’s all getting very messy, but I guess it always has been!
The highlands have been abused for centuries now. The irony of this episode is not lost on me- the people giving a Disney style “Braveheart” shout of “freedom” are a phoney as the film of the same name.
ian512
14 June 2014The abuse (which it is) caused by windfarms and new hill tracks, appears to particulary upset the middle class who see the hills and countryside as their playground; take a bench up Ben Nevis at your peril.
Yet those fun activities themselves have an abusive impact. For example; I've read recently about litter and excrement in remote parts of the hills, footpath scars, rubbish in bothies and litter from a large cycle event in gardens and along the roadside of the route.
iantoandsue
23 June 2014I'm glad I've finished my Munros (and tops!). I enjoyed every minute - except for The Midge!. I've had some wonderful experiences both of the landscape and the people. Not so sure that I'd want to do it now though.
ian512
24 June 2014Most hills didn't have the obvious scarred paths on them before the Munro phenomenon.
Ben Stobbs
07 July 2014I think most sensible folk realise Alex Salmonds drive for independence has more to do with personal recognition than sound economics. As for Stronelairg, its a tragic national disgrace, which should act as a warning of what independence may bring. A United Kingdom has a world wide presence and hitting power way above it's weight, which the UK will retain while an independent Scotland becomes a minnow in a loch full of pike.......